I sometimes ♥ (heart) the Third Circuit

About a week ago, the Third Circuit Court of Appeals heard argument about a school's attempt to ban t-shirts and wristbands with the "I ♥ boobies" slogan on them.  This appeal is being closely watched because it can have a wide-reaching effect.  The prior decision was that the phrase has to be understood in its context, but -- as pointed out by the school's attorney during last week's argument -- what then of other good intentioned slogans such as the "feel my balls" slogan of the testicular cancer organization. 

There are various standards for limiting student speech.  The most often cited one is the Tinker standard that requires a substantial disrpution.  It is a high, but not impossible standard to meet for a school. 

The standard that is at the ♥ of this matter (ha!) is from Fraser, where the U.S. Supreme Court said that a school may ban lewd and vulgar speech taking place at school.  The Third Circuit panel hearing this case stated its feeling that the school would not meet the Tinker standard but might meet Fraser.

It is a slippery slope, so the danger is that were the court to allow this slogan, will the court tailor its decision closely enough so that it will not take away a school's discretion to ban something more clearly lewd?  With the success of the "I ♥ boobies" campaign for public awareness through its shock value, you can be sure that there will be others pushing the limits even further.

The lower court's opinion and order can be found here, although it will be what the Circuit Court says that really matters.

Trackbacks (0) Links to blogs that reference this article Trackback URL
Comments (0) Read through and enter the discussion with the form at the end
Post A Comment / Question Use this form to add a comment to this entry.

Remember personal info?
Send To A Friend Use this form to send this entry to a friend via email.